5.9 Research Questions

The questions below apply specifically to the Neolithic period in the Highlands. Some research questions in the Land and Environment section 3.9 may also apply to the Neolithic period.

Many research questions from the original National ScARF and other regional research frameworks are also relevant and applicable in the Highlands. These will soon be all be searchable and available all together through our our new digital platform facility.

5.9.1 Introductory Questions

HARF Qu 5.1: What happened to the indiginous hunter-fisher-forager communities when immigrant farmers first appeared?

More information on this question
More information:
For how long did their lifestyle persist/survive? Did they choose to acculturate into farming communities?
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

HARF Qu 5.2: Do any shell middens in the Highland Region date to the fourth and early third millennia?

More information on this question
More information:
if they do, are they evidence for the persistence of a Mesolithic lifestyle or for the adoption of the practice of shellfish exploitation by farmers, and do they also contain bones of domesticated animals?
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

HARF Qu 5.3: What happened to the farming communities when Beaker-using immigrants from the Continent arrived around 2500 BC, and what were the dynamics of the relationships between these two groups?

More information on this question
More information:
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

HARF Qu 5.4: Are the apparently ‘blank’ areas on the archaeological map for the Neolithic period in Highland Region blank because people did not live there during the Neolithic, or because the evidence for their presence has not yet been found?

More information on this question
More information:
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

5.9.2 Environmental Questions

HARF Qu 5.5: What, if any, effect did the variations in storminess have on farming practices and the location of settlements?

More information on this question
More information:
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

HARF Qu 5.6: How much blanket peat coverage was there during the Neolithic period, and can its expansion be mapped in detail?

More information on this question
More information:
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

5.9.3 Settlement

HARF Qu 5.7: What was the nature of Neolithic settlement?

More information on this question
More information:
Scattered individual farmsteads? Any nucleated settlements? Any temporary sites (eg shielings)?– and did it vary from area to area within Highland Region, or over time?
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

HARF Qu 5.8: What was the nature of coastal settlement/activity in areas that are now sandhills?

More information on this question
More information:
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

HARF Qu 5.9: Did people live at the sites, such as Littleferry, that Richard Bradley has suggested operated as ‘coastal havens’ for interaction and exchanges?

More information on this question
More information:
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

5.9.4 Landscape

HARF Qu 5.11: How much of the landscape was inhabited (on a permanent or temporary basis) during the Neolithic?

More information on this question
More information:
Did people only live in the areas of good agricultural land? Can palaeoenvironmental research shed light on this question?
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

5.9.5 Buildings

HARF Qu 5.12: Are there any Early Neolithic ‘halls’ in Highland Region?

More information on this question
More information:
Are the two structures that are known from aerial photos at Balmachree candidates, or do they date instead to the first millennium AD?
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

HARF Qu 5.13: What was the shape and construction of houses at different points during the Neolithic?

More information on this question
More information:
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

5.9.6 Subsistence, Diet and Health

HARF Qu 5.14: What was the full range of foodstuffs in the Neolithic diet?

More information on this question
More information:
Can we find any evidence for the use of leafy vegetables, for example?
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

HARF Qu 5.15: How many domestic animals, and in what proportion (cattle:sheep/goat:pig), would each settlement keep?

More information on this question
More information:
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

HARF Qu 5.17: When, and to what extent, were marine resources consumed?

More information on this question
More information:
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

HARF Qu 5.18: What was the ratio of wild to domesticated foodstuffs in the diet

More information on this question
More information:
Did people hunt, and if so, did hunting provide any more than a minor element in the diet? Were deer exploited – and were their movements managed?
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

5.9.7 Material Culture

HARF Qu 5.19: Can we create finer-grained ceramic typochronologies for the Neolithic pottery in Highland Region?

More information on this question
More information:
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

HARF Qu 5.20: Specifically, what is the date of the Neolithic pottery found in Kenny’s Cairn, Garrywhin, The Ord North and Rubh’ an Dunain?

More information on this question
More information:
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

HARF Qu 5.21: What was the overall currency of Grooved Ware in Highland Region, and was there a chronological overlap with the use of Impressed Ware and Beaker pottery?

More information on this question
More information:
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

HARF Qu 5.22: With flaked lithics, what are the patterns of resource exploitation?

More information on this question
More information:
Might there be other examples of movement of raw materials or finished artefacts in addition to pitchstone and the other materials discussed in the text?
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

HARF Qu 5.23: To what extent, and over what timeframe, was Yorkshire flint imported into Highland Region, and to what extent can patterns of flint exploitation be characterised?

More information on this question
More information:
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

HARF Qu 5.24: How much specialised production of flaked lithic artefacts was taking place during the Neolithic, and which artefacts are the product of specialist production?

More information on this question
More information:
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

HARF Qu 5.25: Was Buchan Ridge flint from the Den of Boddam mines imported into Highland Region?

More information on this question
More information:
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

HARF Qu 5.26: Can an Early Neolithic knapping tradition be clearly identified and differentiated from a Late Mesolithic tradition in Highland Region?

More information on this question
More information:
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

HARF Qu 5.27: From where was the tradition of Levallois-like knapping adopted?

More information on this question
More information:
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

HARF Qu 5.28: Were the two axeheads of Shetland felsite genuinely found in Highland Region, or might Fountaine Walker have acquired them from Shetland?

More information on this question
More information:
Might there be any documentation that relates to the discovery of these axeheads or that describes Walker’s collecting habits?
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

HARF Qu 5.29: Where did the All-Over-Polished flint axeheads originate, and when were they made?

More information on this question
More information:
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

HARF Qu 5.30: Are there more Alpine axeheads lurking in museum collections or private hands?

More information on this question
More information:
More generally, are there more Highland Region axehead finds in addition to the ones listed in Datasheet 5.1?
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

HARF Qu 5.31: What was the overall pattern of resource exploitation for stone axe- and adze-heads?

More information on this question
More information:
What proportion of axeheads are made of non-local materials? Are there correlations between the shape and the material of axeheads?
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

HARF Qu 5.32: Were any maceheads or carved stone balls made in Highland Region?

More information on this question
More information:
If not, from where did they come? Is the range of materials used for maceheads or carved stone balls comparable with that used elsewhere in Scotland? Were Maesmor-type maceheads all made in the same place, or same few places, and can the work of individual stoneworking specialists be recognised in their production?
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

HARF Qu 5.33: How many of the saddle querns found in Highland Region are of Neolithic date?

More information on this question
More information:
An inventory of saddle quern finds is needed.
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

HARF Qu 5.34: What cereals (and/or other plant foods) were ground on saddle querns?

More information on this question
More information:
This can be explored using scientific analysis.
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

5.9.8 Religion and Ritual

HARF Qu 5.35: Are the proposed ‘non-megalithic long mounds’ actually non-megalithic?

More information on this question
More information:
Do they cover the remains of timber mortuary structures or cremation pyre sites?
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

HARF Qu 5.36: Can we refine our proposed typochronology of chamber tombs and other funerary monuments in Highland Region?

More information on this question
More information:
In particular, when were long horned cairns added to pre-existing passage tombs, and when were heel-shaped cairns constructed?
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

HARF Qu 5.37: When were Greadal Fhinn and Rahoy constructed, and do they contain any human remains or artefactual finds?

More information on this question
More information:
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

HARF Qu 5.38: What was the cultural affiliation of the people, of Continental ancestry, who were buried in caves and at An Corran rock shelter?

More information on this question
More information:
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

HARF Qu 5.39: What is the significance of the differences in carbon and nitrogen isotope values for human remains found in caves, in Orkney-Cromarty passage tombs and in Clyde cairns, as noted in Sheridan and Schulting 2020?

More information on this question
More information:
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

HARF Qu 5.40: Is the Balintore cist a one-off variant of funerary practice, or are there other Neolithic cist graves waiting to be discovered?

More information on this question
More information:
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

HARF Qu 5.41: During the Early Neolithic, what was the full range of funerary rites afforded to the dead?

More information on this question
More information:
Did everyone reside in a funerary monument, for a certain length of time? Or were most bodies disposed of in a way that has left no archaeological trace?
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

HARF Qu 5.42: Was cremation the only funerary rite used during the Late Neolithic?

More information on this question
More information:
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

5.9.9 Ritual and Special Places

HARF Qu 5.43: Are  there any mortuary enclosures, cursus monuments or bank barrows in Highland Region?

More information on this question
More information:
Is the Culduthel Phase 9 structure a mortuary enclosure, a cursus, or something else? When was it created?
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

HARF Qu 5.44: Are there any major Neolithic gathering sites in Highland Region?

More information on this question
More information:
What enclosures exist in Highland Region?
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

HARF Qu 5.46: Do any stone circles (excluding relics of Clava Cairns, and excluding the Armadale example) date to this period?

More information on this question
More information:
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

HARF Qu 5.47: When was the rock art created? And how was it used?

More information on this question
More information:
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

5.9.10 Movement and Transport

HARF Qu 5.48: What were the patterns of lifetime movement among the Neolithic inhabitants of Highland Region?

More information on this question
More information:
Was it only members of an elite that got to travel long distances? Were there patterned movements associated with marriage rules?
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

HARF Qu 5.49: Did patterns of movement change over the course of the Neolithic?

More information on this question
More information:
What was the nature of the contact across the Pentland Firth that led to the sharing of design ideas for funerary monuments and pottery, etc? We need isotopic data to address some of these questions
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

HARF Qu 5.50: Did the experience of travelling to Orkney during the Late Neolithic alter the social organisation of the inhabitants of Highland Region?

More information on this question
More information:
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

HARF Qu 5.51: Were cattle used for traction during the Neolithic in the Highland Region?

More information on this question
More information:
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

5.9.11 Conflict

HARF Qu 5.52: Are there further examples of inter-personal conflict waiting to be discovered among the Neolithic human remains from Highland Region?

More information on this question
More information:
This is unlikely, however, as the remains have been fairly thoroughly examined.
Status:
Active
Authority to change status:
Date accepted:
09/01/2021
Date of next review:
09/01/2024
Found in the following Frameworks:
The Scottish Archaeological Research Framework

Are there research questions that you think are missing?

Why not add your comment below which will be flagged to ScARF (or get in touch with ScARF directly) and new questions will be considered for addition at the next revision.

Leave a Reply