Case Study: Kinbeachie Neolithic settlement

Susan Kruse

Kinbeachie (MHG58909) on the north side of the Black Isle provides a good example of a site located by repeated fieldwalking. First the farmer, then a local field club, found flint and pottery, and the farmer paid for his own radiocarbon dates. This then led to Historic Scotland doing a geophysical survey followed by trial trenching. All radiocarbon dates and the finds except for one beaker sherd show that the site was used in the Neolithic between 3500 and 2920 BC, providing a good snapshot of Neolithic occupation. The excavators felt that the occupation may have been as short as one generation in this period. It is located in an area with a number of chambered cairns, but this is the first indication of settlement.

The site is important because it was one of the first indications of Neolithic structures on the Highland mainland, showing a number of post holes in a roughly rectangular pattern (Figure 1). This in turn led to similar sites being identified in the Highlands, particularly around Inverness, and further help in interpreting the structure underneath the Raigmore Bronze Age cairn (MHG45837). The nature of the structure – whether domestic or ritual – remains unclear, although there may of course be overlap in functions.

Figure 1: Plan showing location of the excavated features at Kinbeachie. (Barclay et al 2001: 60)

The site had a number of pits which produced Impressed Ware pottery (at least eight vessels), also found in the rectangular structure (Figure 2). Some had clearly been used for cooking. The radiocarbon dating provides important evidence for the dating of Impressed Ware in the Highlands. The presence of a number of pits with Neolithic remains is similar to a number of sites subsequently excavated at other sites in the area.

Figure 2: Vessel 1 from Kinbeachie. (Barclay et al 2001: 65)

There were also a number of lithics, many of flint, and other worked stone found in the fieldwalking and excavation (Figure 3). These included a leaf-shaped arrowhead, a small, polished stone axehead, probably made from local stone, flint scrapers and other flakes and retouched pieces. These were probably not made on site because of the relatively small amount of debitage and the fact use-wear analysis showed that almost all were used. The axehead was unused, and may be ritual given its small size and polished surface.

Figure 3: Worked stone from Kinbeachie – 1: Axehead; 2:-3: serrated blades; 4: bifacial leaf point. (Barclay et al 2001: 72)

The environmental evidence from the excavation showed naked barley and some emmer wheat, again linking the site to common Neolithic evidence. Seeds of agricultural weeds and plants from non-agricultural habitats were almost entirely lacking, but there were hazel nuts and a stone from a Prunus species. Acid soils would have destroyed bone evidence, and only a small amount of burnt bone was found.

The excavators concluded that ‘The simplest interpretation is perhaps that the site was a small farming settlement comprising one or more small rectangular timber buildings. Crops of barley and wheat were cultivated and wild foods such as hazel nuts and cherries were gathered…These settlements are not readily detected by standard archaeological prospection techniques (field-walking, geophysical survey and aerial reconnaissance… The results from Kinbeachie suggest that if these elusive Neolithic settlement sites are to be identified, much greater attention needs to be paid to isolated records of specifically Neolithic finds, especially pottery, as well as the major lithic scatters which can too easily dominate the results of field-walking projects. It is also important to note that if a site is regularly yielding pottery after ploughing it must be experiencing increasing plough truncation. The long-term preservation of shallow near-surface archaeological features is unlikely to be possible and the only course of action that can be recommended is prompt excavation’ (Carter and Dalland 2001, 76).’

The finds are in Inverness Museum and Art Gallery.

Further information

Barclay Gordon J, Carter, Stephen P, Dalland, Magnar M, Hastie, Mhairi, Holden, Timothy G, MacSween, Anne and Wickham-Jones, Caroline R 2001 ‘A possible Neolithic settlement at Kinbeachie, Black Isle Highland’, Proc Soc Antiq Scot 131, 57-85. 

Wordsworth, Jonathan 2003. ‘Kinbeachie Farm, Black Isle.An arable farm with buried archaeology’, CSA Rural Archaeology Case Study 1.