Case Study: Four Caves at Geodha Smoo, Sutherland

Grace Wooler-White with contributions from Susan Kruse

The Geodha Smoo inlet near Durness, Sutherland, is home to a series of coastal caves. Four of these have been subject to limited excavation, which has provided valuable information of multiperiod occupation from possibly the Mesolithic to Norse periods. The most famous cave, Smoo Cave (MHG11597), has had the most attention but another three, named by the excavators as Glassknapper’s Cave (MHG29334), Antler Cave MHG29332) and Wetweather Cave (MHG29333), were investigated afterwards by GUARD in 1995 as part of a rescue excavation of coastal midden deposits.

The excavations revealed a complex story, with sometimes finds of very different dates in the same layers. Unfortunately there were very few radiocarbon dates, which means that most dating is based on artefactual evidence. The dates which were undertaken, one in Smoo Cave, and three from a spit taken in Glassknapper’s cave, all show dating from the later early medieval Period or earlier years of the medieval period.

Figure 1: The entrance to Smoo Cave © Andrew Puls/Highland Council

Early finds reported from Smoo Cave described artefacts reminiscent of Oban Mesolithic objects although, unfortunately, these were kept by the finders. While the excavators felt that Smoo Cave might also have early deposits, the clearest evidence was from Wetweather Cave, which had sherds of Neolithic pottery. An Iron Age midden in Smoo Cave and Iron Age pottery from Glassknapper’s cave showed occupation in later prehistoric times.

Of special significance from the sites was evidence of Norse activity: a copper alloy pin (reminiscent of examples from Freswick, Caithness) was recovered and the radiocarbon dates from Smoo Cave and Glassknapper’s Cave have provided dating between 8th – 12th centuries. Associated deposits produced valuable evidence of the use of marine and other resources in this period, including fish bones, marine shells and mammal and bird bones. The dating of the caves to the Viking period, when we have no settlements and only pagan graves in this region of Scotland (such as at nearby Balnakeil; (MHG11310) is significant, and suggests the likelihood of possible Viking or Norse occupation sites nearby which have, so far, remained elusive except for Borralie (MHG48619).

Full time occupation in any of the caves appeared unlikely, although grain processing evidence of oat and hulled barley makes it impossible to rule out entirely. The majority of the evidence suggested that if there was occupation, it was likely to have only been on a temporary basis. The caves today, with the exception of Wetweather Cave, are relatively shallow and exposed, and the depth of the deposits which have accumulated indicates that the past floor surface would have been even lower. Storm incursions at the very least would have thus been unavoidable and some modification to the caves would have been necessary to make them inhabitable. However, no convincing evidence of this was discovered. Additionally, the artefact assemblage recovered does not reflect full time settlement either; very little pottery was present and there was a lack of other domestic artefacts which would be expected if a settlement had been present. Bone combs, for example, have been found to be fairly common at Norse settlement sites, but none were found in the caves.

The environmental and artefactual evidence, and the marine context of the caves, indicated that the caves were used as seasonal bases for a limited range of specialised crafts and resource exploitation focused on the sea. Particularly significant among the environmental evidence was the presence of Nucella lapillus, a non-edible type of whelk used for the extraction of purple dye. The majority of these shells were from the midden deposit also containing the probable Norse pin in Wetweather Cave, and it represents the first recorded site in Scotland with evidence for this industry. There was also evidence for the production of bone and antler tools, and several example of these worked bone tools were well preserved due to the favourable conditions produced by the shell middens. The function of these tools could not be definitively assigned but it has been suggested that some may relate to the maintenance of boats.

Iron nails of the type known to have been used for the construction of Viking and later vessels were recovered from both Smoo and Glassknapper’s Cave. The discovery of iron slag may indicate that these were being produced on site as well, but the clench nails themselves had clearly already been used; they must have previously been attached to a boat timber that had decayed away or been burnt. They suggest some form of boat repairs had been undertaken in the caves.

Figure 2: Glassknapper’s Cave looking out towards Geodha Smoo inlet © Andrew Puls/Highland Council

Since Geodha Smoo forms a natural harbour, it is unsurprising that it was utilised by the Vikings, attractive as a sheltered location for the repair of their boats. The question posed by this is whether the use of this site by the Norse was as part of a larger settlement pattern within the northwest of Scotland, or if the evidence in the caves resulted from the use of them as temporary stopovers by Norse mariners on journeys. Only further work at the sites and identification of new sites in the region will answer this question.

For a programme of relatively limited excavation, the fours caves at Geodha Smoo have produced significant amounts of information. In light of the general scarcity of excavation work in the northwestern corner of mainland Scotland, their contribution is all the more valuable. As organic artefacts are usually lost on other sites, cave sites containing shell middens thus have the potential to preserve them and produce valuable information, as demonstrated by the caves investigated at Geodha Smoo.

Further information

Highland Historic Environment Records:

Smoo Cave (MHG11597)

Glassknapper’s Cave (MHG29334)

Antler Cave MHG29332)

Wetweather Cave (MHG29333)

Pollard, Tony 2005 ‘The excavation of four caves in the Geodha Smoo near Durness, Sutherland’, Scottish Archaeological Internet Reports 18.